A 'Slow Burn' On 'Temptation Island': Did Yamen And Tayler Keep In Touch?

Tyler Breshears’s relationship with Tayler Byrd fizzled out quickly on "Temptation Island."

While he initially tried to act as if things weren’t over, it became clear early on that his attention had shifted, particularly toward Kay Carlson. Though it wasn’t as outwardly shocking as Brion Whitley’s infamous threesome, Tyler’s connection with Kay was more emotionally charged.

From "cuddling with Kay" and private confessions to the cameras, Tyler's focus had clearly moved on, and shortly thereafter, so did Tayler's, who found a spark with Yamen Sanders. After spending meaningful time together, she chose him for her final overnight date, giving fans hope that she might find a fresh start.

However, in the end, Tayler opted to leave "Temptation Island" solo, choosing to end things with Tyler for good and prioritize herself moving forward, though she and Yamen still keep in touch to this day.

While there was a lot of heartbreak for Tayler throughout "Temptation Island," there is one silver lining: her slow-burn connection with Yamen.

“I mean, it’s funny, things between her and me were a slow burn for the most part, but they started getting pretty nice there towards the end," he said during the reunion, which The Blast got a sneak peek of. "There were definitely some emotions involved, and we really enjoyed each other."

After the show ended, Yamen acknowledged that the women were dealing with a lot emotionally, especially coming off fresh breakups and the overall mental toll of the experience. Given everything going on, it was natural that communication between him and Tayler faded for a bit.

Despite that brief disconnect, they eventually reconnected and are now in frequent contact.

While he didn’t offer a definitive label, Yamen said they talk every day and genuinely enjoy each other’s company, leaving the door open for whatever may come next.

"We enjoy each other's company, we talk every day, and we are seeing where things go," he said, but if his smile is any indication, it's clear the two could become exclusive very soon.

Tayler and Tyler entered "Temptation Island" hoping to prove they were meant for each other.

Their relationship began shortly after Tyler’s separation from his wife, meaning he never had a period of independence or casual dating before jumping into another serious commitment. While Tyler wanted the chance to explore and date before fully settling down, Tayler was seeking reassurance that he wouldn’t repeat past mistakes, namely, cheating.

Before stepping onto the island, the couple agreed they wouldn’t engage physically with any of the singles.

But that promise didn’t hold. Early in the experience, Tyler formed a strong connection with one of the singles, Kay Carlson. During a bonfire, Tayler shared her heartbreak and revealed a deeper emotional struggle, believing that because people in her life consistently leave, she must somehow be the problem.

Host Mark L. Walberg offered heartfelt reassurance, reminding her she wasn’t to blame for others’ choices, though it took time for that message to sink in.

Over the course of the season, Tayler began to rediscover her self-worth. Her emotional growth became a highlight of the show, and she even formed a physical connection with tempter Yamen, showing viewers she was ready to move on.

Tayler’s journey was further shaped by her bond with tempter Case Bruton.

In the early episodes, Tayler felt drawn to Case, appreciating how easy he was to talk to and how deeply he listened. But just as their connection was beginning to blossom, Case chose to self-eliminate, believing it was in her best interest. The decision was a painful one for Tayler, reinforcing a familiar fear that men always walk away.

In a surprising twist, Case returned in episode six, admitting he had unfinished business with Tayler and wanted a second chance. Mark encouraged her to approach the situation without pressure, emphasizing that she didn’t owe forgiveness but could be open to the possibility that not everyone leaves.

For Tayler, this moment was a turning point, a chance to believe that she is worthy of love that stays.

While he stayed on the island, Tayler ultimately decided to choose Yamen to go on her final overnight date, which led to Case leaving the island single. Based on his social media, it seems that Case is still an eligible bachelor.

"Temptation Island" is now streaming on Netflix.