data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/64e7f/64e7f8abc1f9cb447ade72583b4b1da7c2d4cbdc" alt="The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives"
'Mormon Wives' Star’s Surprise Announcement Has Fans Doing A Double Take; Is There A 4th Pregnancy?
By Melanie VanDerveer on February 23, 2025 at 4:30 PM EST
Updated on February 23, 2025 at 4:43 PM EST
It's been a wild month for pregnancy announcements for one popular reality show. Three of the eight stars announced they are expecting, shocking many fans with the exciting news.
Just as the pregnancy news announcements seemed to quiet down, one more star of "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" shared a video that had viewers doing a quick double take before laughing at the joke.
Three 'Mormon Wives' Stars Announced Pregnancies This Month
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6a1f1/6a1f1916e921bbb32f9ba1bd2ba76ea7c73cf22b" alt=""The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives""
The cat's out of the bag - times three!
Three of the eight stars of the hit Hulu reality series, "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" have made pregnancy announcements this month - Jen Affleck, Mikayla Matthews, and Mayci Neeley.
First Affleck shared that she's expecting her third baby, then Matthews shared she's pregnant with her fourth, and finally, Neeley announced that she's expecting her third baby.
"It’s so exciting to have two other friends and castmates on the same journey!" Affleck told PEOPLE. Matthews added, "I've never been pregnant with a friend or anyone at the same time. It's so fun. I feel like we're all so close and it was such a shock. Obviously, we weren't all planning to get pregnant at the same time, so finding out how close [our due dates] are was really fun."
Jessi Ngatikaura Wanted In On The Pregnancy Announcement Fun!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1e423/1e423a00ef8a1c451ee7be412425c771d1412427" alt="The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives"
For a split second, "Mormon Wives" fans on TikTok thought there might be a fourth cast member pregnant after watching Jessi Ngatikaura's newest TikTok video.
The video that quickly went viral with more than 2 million views, is simply captioned, "Incoming." In the video, Ngatikaura is in the middle of Neeley and Matthews in the pool and at one point, all three were holding their bellies.
While two of the three have growing baby bumps, Ngatikaura revealed, "I had a big lunch," in the comical video.
Viewers Asked If There's A 'Pregnancy Pact' With The 'Mormon Wives'
Many fans took to the comments, some with confusion and others to crack jokes. Some viewers seemed to totally miss the joke and believe that there is a fourth "Mormon Wives" baby on the way. But others caught on quickly and shared some humor.
Not missing a beat, Ngatikaura's husband, Jordan, replied, "So excited for our new baby."
"Wait is the whole cast preg rn??!!" one viewer asked. Another wrote, "What is this? The pregnancy pact?" And one other fan said, "Omg you got me! But can’t wait for season 2."
Jessi Ngatikaura Is Ready To Be The 'Cool Aunt'
Before making fans do a double take thinking there's a fourth baby in the works, Ngatikaura shared a video on TikTok to say she's going to be the "cool aunt" to the newest members of the MomTok crew.
Captioned, "When your besties get pregnant at the same time," she shared on the video, "Reminding the babies who their cool aunt is."
Hulu dropped into the comments to say, "cool auntie in the house," and Neeley shared, "Our fav aunty."
One viewer said, "I thought this was gonna be your pregnancy announcement now too I had to sit down before watching." Another fan added, "Everyone needs that cool aunt."
Three MomTok Moms Are Pregnant While Filming Season 2 Of 'The Secret Lives Of Mormon Wives'
View this post on Instagram
Season 2 of "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" is currently filming and the cast seems to be growing by leaps and bounds.
And while filming a reality show can be exhausting, especially with tons of consistent drama, as is the case with this crew, filming while pregnant adds another layer of exhaustion for the three expecting moms.
"Me and Mikayla have talked about how filming a show and being pregnant would be hard," Neeley told PEOPLE. "When you're pregnant, you're insecure. Your body's changing, your face is changing, and so I feel like that's a part that hasn't really hit me yet."
She added, "Luckily, I wasn't too far along filming this last bit, but I am a little worried about seeing myself in the future after filming pregnant. I'm not looking forward to that, because it can be hard on your self-esteem."
Affleck, who was the first of the three MomTok moms to announce her pregnancy, shared a tip for anyone who is pregnant, "listen to your intuition and your body - trust what it needs."