Andy Cohen Talks Jen Shah's Involvement with Heather Gay's Black Eye

Andy Cohen is finally making it clear what he believes happened to Heather Gay’s eyein season three of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City.

The Bravo executive shocked fans on Watch What Happens Live when he confessed that he believes that Jen Shah did indeed clock her so-called bestie Heather right in the eye after a hard night of partying.

The confession came about when the late-night host asked his guest Lala Kent who she believes balled up their first and connected it to Heather’s eye. “I think it’s from a cast member,” claimed Lala like many of the fans of the show believe.

To many of his audience member's surprise, Cohen agreed with Lala. He finished Lala’s sentence by adding “From Jen Shah? I do too. I don’t think she hit her head on a cabinet and got scratches on her arm.”

The most that Andy has spoken or tried to speak on the debacle is the more he was shut down by the like of Heather and Jen. First, Jen didn’t show up to the reunion, so no one could ask her anything.

Then we have Heather who was present and accounted for and delivers a story about having zero recollection of what happened and played up the fact that someone hit her because of her “Mormon shame”. Drinking too much and talking too much about men’s penises.

Finally, the other women have no idea what happened and when they are pushed to find out it turned into chaos that made no sense to the viewers. Heather admitted “I blacked out,” on part one of the reunion. She went on to clarify “I don’t know how it happened.”

Heather recalls, the morning after, “I woke up terrified. I had my phone plugged in, I was in pajamas.” She continued on to use words like “scared”, and “traumatized” to describe her emotional state.

Heather admitted that she played up the mystery of it all because she didn’t want to give the other women the opportunity to “rewrite the narrative”. She explained, “When production came into my room, I told them, I said, ‘I have no idea, I have no memory,’” she recalls.

“And then it spun out of control after that, and I take full responsibility, and I’m really sorry. It’s terrifying.” By the end of that wonky explanation, Heather had disproved her explanation by admitting she remembers who hit her but won’t say it because she doesn’t want to get anyone in trouble.

When the incident initially happened, Heather used the black eye as a way to trigger and bait the women in the house to turn against one another. She threatened more than once to say who did it and get a lot of people in trouble.

However, she also told Jen in the heat of the moment, “I don’t wanna get anyone in trouble,” and admitted that she needed help recalling. “So that’s why I need you to help me figure out if someone wants to talk about what really happened last night.”

At this point, some of the cast like Whitney Rose believe Jen hit Heather and many of the fans believe the same thing. Now, Andy is admitting he also thinks so too.