Fans didn’t really expect these two to say “I Do” at the altar!

Kyle was an atheist and Shaina was a very devout Christian.

Although Kyle was willing to compromise, Shaina wasn’t having it.

She eventually let him meet her family… but that didn’t go so well.

After that awkward encounter, they called it quits for good.

After the season 2 finale, Kyle told Us Weekly that they haven’t spoken at all since the breakup.

“We don’t communicate,” he said. “There’s nothing left.”

“We’re not friends or anything,” he added.

He admitted he didn’t “wanna quit” on their relationship, saying, “I did everything I could do.”