‘PLL’ Star Shay Mitchell Breaks Her Tooth After Eating Too Many Bagel Sandwiches

Shay Mitchell probably didn’t think her day would end with a trip to the dentist but that’s exactly what happened when she broke her moneymaker after eating bagel sandwiches.

The “Pretty Little Liars” star posted the hilarious video, showing one of her top lateral incisors completely knocked out while she sat in a dentist chair on Wednesday.

“This is what happens when you eat a bagel sandwich, your tooth comes out,” Shay says. “This is what I get for eating two bagel sandwiches. Damn it!”

Here’s a little backstory — earlier in the day, her friend, who started an “off the menu” app, brought her some bagels from Yeastie Boys. While Shay doesn’t directly say these are the bagels that knocked out her pearly whites, it’s safe to assume they were.

Considering how awesome bagels are, we’d say it was all worth it.

Pretty Little Liars cast photos
Getty