The Blast and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.
The Best Eyeshadow Pencils: An Essential In Your Makeup Routine
Last updated: 1 Dec 2022
The era of powdered makeup is almost over. Cream blushes, contour sticks, and eyeshadow pencils are the new hype. Eyeshadow pencils specifically have the advantage of being quicker because you do not need to prime your eyes as much before applying them. With powdered eyeshadow, layering is very important to achieve the right pigmentation. With an eyeshadow pencil, you apply it all over your eyelid and blend it in with your finger. The cream consistency of eyeshadow pencils means that there is no eyeshadow fallout, which can be a hassle to clean. A lot of makeup artists and professionals have started relying on eyeshadow pencils and for good reason. If you are looking for a good eyeshadow pencil, you have come to the right place. We have listed the top-rated eyeshadow pencils, so you can choose the one most suitable for you.
Eyeshadow pencils are essential for your daily makeup routine. You can quickly apply a bit before going to the office or joining an online meeting, even if you are late. Eyeshadow pencils have a lot of uses other than just applying to your eyelids. We will talk about these in our buyer’s guide below.
The Julep eyeshadow pencil is easily our first choice. It is a cream to powder pencil that is very easy to apply. The formula will not crease on your eyelids and it is waterproof, so your makeup will stay protected from moisture. Vitamin E and C are infused in this formula so it will be ideal for all skin types, including sensitive skin.
The finish of this eyeshadow pencil is matte. The best thing about this product is the built-in smudger. After applying the pencil, you can easily use it to blend the color in, and you will not need an eyeshadow brush. The ingredients list is free from harmful ingredients like parabens, and the company does not test on animals.
This is our second choice due to its texture that slides on perfectly. It does not smudge, crease, or clump. The consistency of this eyeshadow stick is perfect and the thick end allows you to apply a large amount at one go. The stick does not need to be sharpened and you just need to twist it to use it.
A blending brush is included so you do not need to carry an extra makeup brush for touch ups. One pack includes six pieces, and you can choose from different shades. The eye pencil is long lasting and will stay on for about 5 to 10 hours. The application is subtle, but you can layer it on if you are going for a glam look.
Our third choice is NYX, which is a famous drugstore brand. Their jumbo eye pencil is a versatile cosmetic. You can use it as a cream eyeshadow, an eyeliner, and a highlighter. You can even apply it onto your water line. It is very easy to apply.
The white one can be used as a base for your eyeshadow, or you can choose from the wide range of colors and finishes available. Most of these are the perfect combination of creamy and matte. The company is cruelty free and has been certified by PETA. The only problem with this pencil is it does not have the swivel twist function. You will need to sharpen it with a jumbo sharpener.
The Focallure eyeshadow pencil checks all the boxes of the qualities needed in a good eyeshadow pencil. This pack has three pieces and they are a two-in-one, eyeshadow, and eyeliner pencil. The pigmentation is amazing and the formula is both waterproof and crease-proof.
It will last all day and the smooth, creamy formula glides on perfectly, eliminating the need of using a brush. Some of the shades have a lot of shimmers and you can use them as a highlighter. The formula is hypoallergenic so it is suitable for sensitive skin as well. The company does not test its products on animals and it has a twist open technique.
Last but not the least, the Glo Skin Beauty eyeshadow stick is one of the best ones in the market. The formula is neither too shiny, nor too matte; it is just the perfect blend. Twelve different shades are available and you can use them as an eyeshadow pencil or as a highlighter.
The product is safe to use on the waterline as well. It is ideal for all skin types, even sensitive ones because no harmful ingredients have been incorporated into this eyeshadow pencil. The twist open function makes it convenient to use and it will blend perfectly with your fingers. There is no need for a makeup brush. The eyeshadow pencil will stay on for about 12 hours.
Finding Your Next High-Quality Eyeshadow Pencil: Buying Guide
Eyeshadow pencils are easily the most versatile product used for eye makeup. Their cream consistency allows you to use it as a blush, highlighter, and eyeliner, and you can even apply it on your waterline. We have provided useful tips and tricks in this guide so that you can make the most out of your eyeshadow pencil.
Why Do You Need an Eyeshadow Pencil?
Eyeshadow pencils have gained popularity over the years, and for good reason. The major advantages of eyeshadow pencils include convenience, ease of use, and time-saving. A wide range of colors are available and several brands are manufacturing them. You can choose the one that meets your specific needs and preferences. The consistency of most eyeshadow pencils is creamy, which means better pigmentation. Powder shadows need a proper base, and to achieve the required color, you need to layer it on. With cream eyeshadows, you do not need to prime or layer, unless you are going for a complete glam look. This helps save time and you do not need to put in as much effort.
For everyday use, you can apply them directly onto your eyes without priming and achieve a subtle look. They are convenient because they can be blended well with your fingers, which makes it perfect for touch ups.
Some pencils come with a built-in smudger or brush which completely eliminates the need of using a makeup brush. Moreover, powder eyeshadow has the annoying problem of fallout, which is difficult to clean.
You will not face this problem with an eyeshadow pencil because the cream formula means no fallout at all.
How Else Can an Eyeshadow Pencil Be Used?
As we said before, there are numerous ways of utilizing your eyeshadow pencil. If you are applying it to your eyes, blending it with a brush or your finger as needed is sufficient. But, how else can you use it?
Bright-colored eyeliners have become popular, but it is difficult to find a quality one in all the colors. It is relatively easier to find different colors in eyeshadow pencils. You can use them to apply eyeliner both on your lids and even in your waterline. This gives you more control over your makeup and you can move on from the boring, black eyeliner every time.
Cream blushes are also a favorite, especially for those who have dry skin.
With the right shades like pink, peach, or rosy, you can utilize an eyeshadow pencil as a cream blush. This is particularly helpful when you need a quick touch-up because you will only need to carry an eyeshadow pencil in your bag for both your eyes and cheeks.
A lot of eyeshadow pencils come in shimmery shades. These specifically are useful for using as a highlighter. Sometimes, powdered highlighters do not give the glow that you are looking for, and a cream highlighter is not always available. Simply apply a line onto your cheekbones and blend with your finger.
How to Pick the Right Eyeshadow Pencil
With so many brands around the world manufacturing eyeshadow pencils, it can become overwhelming to pick the correct one for you. Even browsing all the different brands is a tedious process, but do not fret because we are here to help you. Consider these few factors so that your shopping process can become easier and shorter.
A lot of brands are providing sets that include more than one color.
We think it is better to invest in these rather than buying individual ones. Not only are these more reasonable, but you will have several color shades to choose from. Some sets include both matte and shimmery shades, so choose one accordingly.
Your eyes are the most sensitive part of your body, so you should not compromise and be careful about what you apply on them. Make sure the eyeshadow pencil you buy does not contain harmful substances like parabens. Purchasing a hypoallergenic one is better, even if you do not have sensitive skin, because it reduces the chances of getting an infection.
Additionally, always do a patch test before you start using one.
Waterproof eyeshadow pencils are a good option because they do not crease or smudge with sweat. If you live in a hot or humid climate, make sure your eyeshadow pencil is waterproof. These also tend to last longer than non-waterproof ones.
Always purchase from brands that are cruelty-free and do not test their products on animals. It is our duty as responsible citizens to protect the environment and its species. In the list of our top picks, we have not included any brand that tests their products on animals. When browsing, if the website does not mention it, you can contact the company and ask.
Eyeshadow pencils are not very expensive. Most brands are selling them below $20. The brands that we have included are mostly drugstore brands that are easily available in the market, so they are reasonable. However, if you purchase from a renowned brand, you will have to pay a higher price.
But it may not be worth spending a lot of money on an eyeshadow pencil when you can get good quality and long-lasting ones at a lower price.
Getting value for what you get charged is vital.
People Also Asked
Q: Are twist up eyeshadow pencils better?
A: Twist up eyeshadow pencils are definitely more convenient to use because you do not need to sharpen it. This means no mess and you can save time. However, these might last for a shorter period of time than those pencils that need to be sharpened.
Q: Can I use all eyeshadow pencils on my waterline?
A: Most eyeshadow pencils are safe to apply on your waterline. However, it is better to be safe than sorry, so always check the ingredients list and confirm with the manufacturer before applying it on your waterline.
Q: Do I really need an eyeshadow pencil?
A: Eyeshadow pencils are definitely easier to use and more convenient than powdered shadows. If you are looking for a daily use eyeshadow that is easy to apply and will not smudge, you should invest in one because it will definitely be worth it.
TheBlast Review Team’s in-depth guides are here to help you find the best products in fashion, beauty, wellness, and more. The content is created by TheBlast Review Team. TheBlast’s editorial staff is not involved. We’re reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.