‘Too Soon’: Fans Split Over An All-Star Season Of ‘The Traitors’

Since a story surfaced that producers are reportedly working on an all-star cast for “The Traitors,” fans of the Peacock series appear sharply divided on the idea.

The report first appeared in The Sun on February 5 and has since sparked intense debate among viewers over the merits of a potential all-star season.

While some argue it’s too early in the show’s run to execute the concept, others have already begun drawing up their fantasy lineups of who they’d like to see return.

The discussion comes against the backdrop of the still-unfolding fourth season, which was previously described by host Alan Cumming as “absolute carnage.”

According to The Sun, Season 6 has been earmarked as the installment to introduce an all-star cast.

The report cited an alleged insider who claimed that while much of the current focus remains on finalizing the cast for the upcoming fifth season, work has already begun behind the scenes on Season 6.

“Traitors’ production are actively casting for Season 5 and putting the finishing touches on that cast,” the source reportedly said. “But they’re also already assembling an All-Star cast for the following year, Season 6, which will be the first time the show’s ever done that.”

There is a clear divide among fans over the idea of an all-star season of “The Traitors.”

Yet even among viewers who oppose the concept, many say their hesitation comes down to timing rather than the idea itself.

In one thread discussing the report on X, a fan suggested that production should wait until Season 7 before attempting an all-star edition.

“We need at least one more season before they consider an all stars,” the user wrote.

That sentiment was echoed by another viewer, who compared the reported plans to “Big Brother’s” approach to all-star casting.

“[It’s] too early,” they said. “Season 7 should be all stars just like ‘Big Brother.’”

The same source quoted by The Sun in the report about a rumored all-star season also provided the names of players they claimed that production is already considering.

Lisa Rinna and Rob Rausch have been two of the main standouts from Season 4 and are listed among the said early favorites to return.

Other contestants who are namechecked include “Survivor” alumni Cirie Fields, Boston Rob Mariano, and Parvati Shallow.

Previous winners Dylan Efron and Gabby Windey are also said to be in the mix, along with “Real Housewives” star Phaedra Parks, who left a strong impression during Season 2.

Beyond the fans concerned by the timing of a likely all-star Season 6 of “The Traitors,” an even more radical view has been emerging around the conversation on social media.

Since its first season, the popular series has been casting celebrities only, with reality TV stars from other shows often dominating the cast.

This fact has made some viewers question whether selecting from among those celebrities for a returnee-only season is not pushing the boat a little too far.

One particular fan warned that having too many massive egos in one season would negatively impact the storytelling.

“It would exacerbate the existing problems of the edit focusing on [a] few big personalities and fan favorites being targeted early or just under-edited overall,” the comment reads.

Before fans get a chance to see a potential all-star Season 6, they will first watch “everyday” people battle it out in the Scottish castle for the first time since the show premiered in 2023.

A promotional poster on the official casting website describes some of the characteristics production is seeking in potential Season 5 contestants.

“In this brand new version for NBC, you do not have to be a celebrity to play!” the advert reads. “We are looking for smart, strategic everyday people to compete in the ultimate game of trust and treachery.”

It remains to be seen whether Season 6 will indeed be an all-star edition, and whether any standout players from the Season 5 cast will factor into those plans.