Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes To Invite Their Now-Dating Ex-Spouses To Their Wedding Despite Fallout Over Affair
By Favour Adegoke on January 15, 2026 at 3:15 PM EST
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes have reportedly extended wedding invitations to their former spouses, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig.
The move comes years after the soon-to-be married couple garnered backlash over their affair while they worked as co-presenters of "GMA3" and the subsequent divorce from their respective exes.
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes' ex-spouses, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, have since started dating and even moved in together.
Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes Want To Invite Their Exes To Their Wedding
The former TV presenters are reportedly extending invitations to their exes, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, three years after a media firestorm erupted over their workplace romance, which led to their firing from "GMA3" and the simultaneous collapse of both their marriages.
According to Us Weekly, they are "not expecting" Shue and Fiebig to show up, even though they extend the invitation, but Robach particularly "wishes they could be a blended and normal family and all get along."
Robach got married to Shue in 2010, but the couple ultimately ended their union after her relationship with Holmes became public, with their divorce finalized in early 2023. Together, they share two children, Ava and Annalise.
On the other hand, Holmes and Fiebig got married in March 2010 and welcomed daughter Sabine in January 2013. However, they went their separate ways in 2023 following their affair scandal.
He's also the father of kids Brianna and Jaiden from his first marriage to Amy Ferson.
The Former News Anchors Reportedly Plan To Shun Their Former 'GMA' Colleagues
Robach and Holmes' children with their respective exes will seemingly play a big role in their upcoming nuptials.
"Amy wants T.J.'s daughter Sabine and her daughters, Ava and Annie, to be bridesmaids," the insider who spoke with Us Weekly said.
They went further to share that the lovebirds' wedding will not be a "celebrity-heavy" event, and will not be attended by "anyone from 'GMA.'"
They seem to be going with a low-key wedding that will have "their closest friends and family, [including] around 50 to 60 guests" in attendance.
T.J. Holmes And Amy Robach Say They Were 'Outed As Adulterers,' And That Was Not The Case
The "Amy & T.J." podcast hosts have had to fight to change the narrative that surrounded their relationship following their ousting from ABC.
Holmes insisted back in December 2023 that they didn't cheat on their respective exes even though they were married to them at the time their affair became public.
"We were outed as being in a relationship, but everyone else thought we were being outed as adulterers — being outed as cheating on our spouses — and it wasn't the case," Holmes claimed, per Page Six. "We both at that point were in divorce proceedings."
Robach agreed, saying they each "had attorneys and mediators [and] were in the middle of divorces."
The Couple Recently Shared The Secret To Their Happy Relationship
In December 2025, the pair dished on the secret to their happy and healthy relationship during a conversation with People Magazine at iHeartRadio's Jingle Ball 2025.
"Friendship, the foundation of friendship, period, point blank," Holmes said, as Robach quipped, "Without a doubt."
He continued, "If you got a friend you love and you respect ... you end up in a relationship that's still the foundation of friendship."
Robach added, "Yes, if you can laugh with someone, you can live a long time with someone. You can get through almost anything if you can laugh together."
The red carpet event seemingly turned into a family affair as the couple posed alongside Holmes' daughter Sabine, and Robach's girls Annalise and Ava.
Did Amy Robach Buy Her Own Engagement Ring?
Meanwhile, their relationship has continued to set tongues wagging, especially after they got engaged in September.
Reports claim Robach likely bought her engagement ring, with an insider claiming that Holmes is "notoriously cheap."
"Amy's net worth is around $50 million. TJ's is about $7 million. Everyone knows she's always had the bigger paycheck. The bigger severance. The bigger savings," an insider said, per the National Enquirer.
Another source alleged, "Amy wanted the fairytale. T.J. wanted the photo op. The ring looks like his taste and her budget."
According to the news outlet, friends are concerned that Robach is taking the lead and paying for it all, both emotionally and financially.
"If she bought her own ring, it wouldn't be the first time she paid for love," a close friend noted.
