Taylor Swift In Revealing Rhinestones Told She Missed 'The Mark'
By Kristin Myers on October 13, 2025 at 8:00 AM EDT

Pop star Taylor Swift might be trying to show off her sexy Showgirl side following the release of her new album, but some fans still can't get on board with the visuals. The "Cruel Summer" singer released several different album variants, also showing off a different Showgirl costume, but it looks like it fell flat for many fans. In addition to her hair not being made up, some have called her out for having a "flat" expression and not conveying the desirability that most showgirls are known for.
Taylor Swift Faces Backlash Over Lackluster Album Artwork
Pre-order The Life of a Showgirl: “It’s Beautiful” Limited Release Deluxe CD now on my site. Available for 72 hours while supplies last. ❤️🔥 https://t.co/rIaG2EzVXx
Album Producers: Max Martin, Shellback and Taylor Swift
📸: Mert Alas & Marcus Piggott pic.twitter.com/9GZ5aJBF7D— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) August 14, 2025
Many fans on social media have said that they are “put off” by the “Anti-Hero” singer’s Showgirl era, with one fan vocalizing on Reddit that the images fell “short of where it is meant to.”
The user admitted that they weren’t sure if it was “intentional” to show “ less makeup, less glitter, hair not done, low lighting, etc.” than a typical showgirl performance, but admitted, “I do feel it is going to miss the mark.”
Taylor’s Facial Expression Comes Under Criticism
The Life of a Showgirl: Baby, That’s Show Business Vinyl Collection is available now on my site for 48 hours while supplies last ❤️🔥https://t.co/WdrCmvLHyA
Album Producers: Max Martin, Shellback and Taylor Swift
📸: Mert Alas & Marcus Piggott pic.twitter.com/ExVQpnEyOk— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) August 21, 2025
One user attributed the lackluster reception of the photos to her facial expressions. “I think it’s the lack of facial expression. When I think of showgirls, there is always a big smile on the face selling the fantasy,” they explained, noting that Taylor looks “uncomfortable in that outfit.”
“Taylor doesn’t look nearly as happy as the showgirls in any of the photos, in smile or body language. She does the big showgirl smile plenty in the actual tour performances, so I assume this is an intentional choice?” another user asked, but fans just couldn’t be sure.
Taylor Swift Told She Doesn’t Display ‘Sexy Confidence’
I hereby invite you to a *dazzling* soirée, The Official Release Party of a Showgirl: Oct 3 - Oct 5 only in cinemas! You’ll get to see the exclusive world premiere of the music video for my new single “The Fate of Ophelia”, along with never before seen behind-the-scenes footage… pic.twitter.com/4gpA1Or2xT
— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) September 19, 2025
Another user pointed out that the “Love Story” singer’s posture in the photos might be leading some of the antagonism, as she seemed “closed off” in the album artwork. “Honestly, I think it’s her shoulders. I know there’s a lot of talk about her posture, and I understand that can be a struggle,” a user wrote. “But for all of her stage training (at least I would assume she’s had stage training), the fact that she can’t get her shoulders back and her chest out is astonishing.”
“The showgirls open themselves up to the stage and the camera. She has closed off body language while seemingly portraying this sexy confidence, and it makes our brains go ?????” they continued, with another fan saying that their take “sums it up perfectly.”
Is She Just Copying An Aesthetic?
A showgirl knows to save some of her best tricks for the grand finale…
The Life of a Showgirl: The Crowd is Your King Edition on Summertime Spritz Pink Shimmer Vinyl is available to pre-order now exclusively at @Target while supplies last ❤️🔥PS: we’re 9️⃣ days away(!!!!!!!!!!!!)… pic.twitter.com/shNleSKEtL
— Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13) September 24, 2025
In other posts, fans have compared her outfit to a "Temu showgirl." In the comments of this post, one user said that it felt like she was wearing a "Halloween costume" instead of trying to show "any understanding" of what it means to be a showgirl.
"Sorry, but it’s giving Halloween costume," they wrote. "She does not seem to have any understanding of what a Showgirl is, and is just copying the aesthetic. It is viscerally cringey to me. I wish she could just be authentic instead of always trying to do a bit."
To see more of Taylor Swift and get the latest updates on her new album and engagement to Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce, follow The Blast on Facebook!