Andy Cohen Responds To The Speculation About His Dating Life: 'They're Right'

Andy Cohen has never been coy about his dating life or his sexual escapades, and he stayed true to that during a recent episode of his radio show, "Andy Cohen Live."

This openness was on full display when Andy Cohen and his ex-boyfriend, John Hill, tackled a rumor about his kissing abilities during a segment, prompting the "Real Housewives" executive producer to share a surprising response.

While speaking with a caller who asked Cohen about a recent rumor on the gossip blog Deuxmoi that suggested he's a great kisser, the father of two wasted no time confirming.

“You know what? Someone did send me that, and they’re right,” Cohen said before Hill seemingly confirmed.

"See that? Wow. Certified by John Hill," Cohen added. "And let me tell you this, he would say if I wasn't. I'm glad that Deuxmoi posted that, and my DM should be lighting up, but they're not."

Later, the caller asked Cohen whether he sent the tip to Deuxmoi, to which he replied, "No, I didn't plant it."

“God knows," he continued. "Listen, I’ve kissed enough people and I’ve never gotten a bad review, so...”

Cohen and Hill's banter on "Andy Cohen Live" isn't the first time the two have joked back and forth about their relationship from the early 2000s.

During a previous episode of "Watch What Happens Live," when Hill was listing "five things" Cohen should do in 2025, one of his answers shook the Bravoverse to its core.

“Release our sex tape from 2003,” Hill said, which clearly caught Cohen by surprise before he burst into laughter.

“You know what? I think there is one,” Cohen revealed before admitting it's not a quality film.

“But the format, it’s on some janky format," he said, to which Hill replied, "It's bad."

Although the two stars can have lighthearted conversations about their relationship today, Hill admitted that their breakup was challenging for him.

On the "Hot Takes and Deep Dives" podcast, the Broadway performer called their split "heartbreaking" and "super sad."

Hill explained that part of the reason for their split was because his and Cohen's careers were going in different directions, and "adjusting to that" would've been more difficult.

He continued, “We always had an intimate connection. We always had an emotional, vulnerable — like an honest, open relationship."

"We were great together. We always made each other laugh. That’s the reason," he added. "We grew apart in terms of boyfriendness. We had the friendship, we had the love, but the boyfriend part was kind of fading.”

Cohen's friendly rapport with Hill isn't the only connection of his that has generated buzz. In 2024, the "WWHL" host opened up about his friendship with longtime friend John Mayer.

When asked about his close relationship with Mayer during a previous conversation, Cohen said he has a lot of "love" for the rock singer, adding, "And he loves me."

“But because we’re so affectionate toward each other, people don’t know what box to put that in," he continued before saying many people assume the two have slept with each other.

Later, on his "Daddy Diaries" podcast, Cohen cleared the air once and for all, saying his statement "should now put an end" to anyone inquiring about the nature of their relationship.

He went on to call the questions "demeaning," adding that there's an assumption that a "gay guy can't be friends with a straight person without them having sex."

Mayer also had something to say about his close friendship with Cohen being a topic of discussion.

"I think that to suggest that people are dubious of a friendship like mine and Andy's is to undermine the public's ability to accept and understand diversity in all facets of culture, be it in art or in real life," Mayer wrote in a statement.

"I'd like to think they're sophisticated enough to see a relationship like ours without assuming it must include a sexual component. That turns the concept of being gay into an ignorantly two-dimensional one, which I know you know it's not. I don't question that at all," he continued.

Mayer added, "Quite simply, if someone is dubious of a platonic relationship between a straight man and a gay man, I don't think that shallow a view deserves clarification by anyone with self-respect."