B.J. Novak first became a household name - or at least a recognizable face - for his appearances as Ryan Howard on the sitcom "The Office" and for his work on the Ashton Kutcher prank show "Punk'd." He had earlier gone to high school with John Krasinski, who played Jim Halpert on the show, at Newton South High School in Newton, Massachusetts, so the two knew each other long before they starred together on the show. (They also played Little League together, according to a 2009 newspaper interview.) "Sometimes when this feels too good to be true, I think that if this were all a dream, that would be what should have tipped me off," he said during an interview with The Philadelphia Inquirer in 2009. I'd wake up saying, "I was in this incredible TV show and it was a big hit and the star was John from high school. Isn't that weird?"