Is anyone else completely shocked? Morgan Lolar and Evan Smith stole our hearts when they fell in love while filming the reality show, Temptation Island. After deciding to leave the island together, fans just knew they were going to last forever. Especially because Evan choosing to leave with Morgan, meant he was ending the 10-year relationship he had with his current girlfriend, Kaci Campbell. But, Evan moved out of the apartment they shared and bought a one-way plane ticket to Morgan’s hometown of Arlington, Virginia.